NFL Drafts of years past have been anxious events. The Colts always seem to have the same needs – defensive tackle, offensive line and linebacker. And with each year come predictions from pundits on who the Colts should select: a fat defensive tackle; big and strong linebackers; and road grating offensive linemen. And, just like clockwork, the Colts go against the grain and select guys no pundit or fan had identified for the Colts … much to the frustration of Colts fans.
I can’t tell you how often I’ve asked myself “who’s that guy?” after a Colts first and second round selection. Hours and hours of research have gone for naught every single year.
This year proved no different with regard to surprise. Colts GM Bill Polian selected RB Donald Brown out of Connecticut with the Colts first round pick; another who’s that guy? in my limited database of college talent.
Here we go again, I think. Another year of Polian going rogue in the draft war room and not following the expectations. But then my perspective changed. After a little back-and-forth texting with @Jason266, I changed my outlook on the move. I started to like rogue Polian in the draft war room. The Colts could’ve gone defensive tackle or linebacker with the first pick, but instead Polian opted to take a RB that could’ve made a difference last year given that Joseph Addai wasn’t 100% for whatever reason. Knowing the Colts weren’t their playoff best until a solid running game was in place, I warmed to the decision.
Then, after I’ve warmed to rogue Polian, he gets conventional and selects defensive tackle Fili Moala. The thing about Moala is that he’s not your typical Colts defensive tackle; rather, he weighs over 300 pounds and can stop the run. What a novel concept! Later I learned on Colts.com that Polian had decided it was time to upgrade the defensive tackle position in order to improve run defense. So much for going against the grain. (EDITOR'S NOTE: It's about effing time, Bill)
The rest of Polian’s draft followed a very conventional approach in terms of need for the Colts. Jerraud Powers, a CB out of Auburn, seems to fit the Colts mold for cornerbacks in that he lacks size, but can cover and tackle.
Fourth round choice Austin Collie – WR, BYU – looks as if he will fill the slot receiver spot while the Colts promote Anthony Gonzalez to the number two spot.
The Colts then traded back up into the fourth round to get another wide-bodied defensive tackle in Terrance Taylor from Michigan. My friend who follows U of M and covers the draft about as intensely as Mel Kiper says that the Colts got a steal, and backed that up with the fact that Taylor was projected as a top 15 pick before the season started and fell down the draft board … partly due to the fact that Michigan had its worst season ever.
The pick I’m most intrigued with is 5th rounder Curtis Painter. If another team had selected Painter, my guess is that he wouldn’t play until his second or third year at least. Now that the Colts have him, he may not play much in the next five years. But consider this: Peyton Manning turns 38 in 5 years. How much time does he have left? I think seven years, but if Peyton hangs it up in five I think Indy has its heir apparent in Painter. Why? Two reasons: 1) He played at Purdue and thus has experience throwing the rock; 2) look no further than the success of his predecessors: Drew Brees and Kyle Orton. Let’s see how this project develops; Painter will learn from the best.
The last two picks all fill a need: the Colts get a potential starting P and future kicker in Pat McAfee and add depth on the offensive line with Maryland guard/tackle Jaimie Thomas.
My bottom line on this year’s draft is this – I like it … a lot. I think the Colts have at least 4 starters: Brown, Moala, Taylor and McAfee. There are two projects in Painter and Collie; one will develop faster than the other. The other two picks add depth at positions where depth was needed. Overall it was a successful draft in my view. Sure, it didn’t warrant an A or B grade from pundits, but it filled several needs.
I’m not sure I’ve been much more pleased with a Polian draft than I am of this one. Big time needs were filled at DT, and we now have a viable situation at RB.
I like where this is headed.